We Put Our Members First.

Personal Insurance Services

Protecting you and your family is what we're all about! With personalized insurance coverage from Members 1st Insurance Services, you can be sure you are protected for the troubles life throws your way.

We offer coverage for:
  • Personal Automobiles
  • Homeowners
  • Recreational Vehicles
  • Condominium
  • Dwelling Fire
  • Personal Umbrella
  • Farmowners
  • Mobile Home
  • Flood
  • Boats
  • Wedding
  • Valuable Items
  • Renters
  • Antique Automobiles

Paying your insurance premiums couldn't be easier. Our flexible payment options include electronic funds transfer (EFT), credit card or payments by mail. Our monthly payment plans are designed to fit your budget, and our pay in full option may provide a potential discount.

What are you waiting for? Request a free, no-obligation auto or home insurance quote and see how much we can save you!

Insurance services are available in Pennsylvania and Maryland only.


Personal Insurance FAQs:

Do you offer free insurance quotes?

YES! For a free auto or homeowners insurance quote, click here.

Can I get a discount if I have more than one type of policy with you?

Yes. One of our licensed professionals will be happy to discuss "bundling" discounts with you and how they can lower your insurance costs.

Are there any other discounts available?

YES! Many of our carriers offer an additional discount to our valued members as a benefit of your membership. Contact us today to learn more about other discounts that you may qualify to receive.

Who Can I Talk To If I Have Questions?

Lisa Richardson   Kari Blood
Lisa Richardson, CISR   Kari Fite
Operations Manager   Account Manager
5000 Louise Drive   5000 Louise Drive
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055   Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
E-Mail: RichardsonL@m1stinsurance.org   E-Mail: FiteK@m1stinsurance.org
   
Clinton Forry   Jolene Kleiser
Clinton Forry   Jolene Kleiser
Account Manager   Account Manager
5000 Louise Drive   5000 Louise Drive
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055   Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
E-Mail: ForryC@m1stinsurance.org   E-Mail: KleiserJ@m1stinsurance.org
   
Leah Warren   Robin Brice
Leah Warren   Robin Brice
Account Manager   Customer Service Support
5000 Louise Drive   5000 Louise Drive
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055   Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
E-Mail: WarrenL@m1stinsurance.org   E-Mail: BriceR@m1stinsurance.org

Contact a M1st Insurance Services Representative Online.


Ask us about bundling discounts!

Ask us about bundling & membership discounts!