Deep discounts on top-rate coverage

Protecting what you care about shouldn’t be complicated or unaffordable. We offer a full range of personal, group, auto, health, and life insurance plans through the most respected insurance companies in the business.


When you choose a personal plan through Members 1st Insurance Services, you get exactly that—a personal insurance plan, crafted by a real person who understands what you need and how to make it happen. We’ll compare options from more than 140 of the country’s top carriers— including Nationwide®, Allstate, Donegal, Travelers, Chubb and more— to find your perfect plan.

Find a plan that works for you

Image containing a car
Auto Insurance

Buckle up and enjoy the ride with a customized auto insurance plan. Our fast and easy-to-use quoting tool allows you to get a fast, free and personalized auto policy quote in as little as two minutes. 

Learn more
Homeowners Insurance

Don't let the unexpected take you by surprise. Get the protection you need for your home sweet home in as little as two minutes with our fast and easy-to-use quoting tool. 

Learn more
Image containing a first aid kit

Navigating Medicare and supplement insurance can feel impossibly complicated. We're here to offer free guidance and help you create a personal action plan.

Learn more
life insurance

The life insurance you choose now will be there when your loved ones need it the most—from maintaining a standard of living to paying off debts and providing for college.

Get started
Image containing a doctor's stethoscope
Long Term Care

Long term care insurance can help you to afford the rising costs of assisted living, nursing homes, hospice care, and more.

Learn more
Image containing money
Lending Insurance

Our Member Value Protection (MVP) allows your loan payments to be put on hold in the case of death, disability, or involuntary unemployment—without penalty or additional interest.

Learn more
Pet Insurance

Nationwide® Pet Insurance offers comprehensive and affordable coverage for prescription medicine, testing, surgery, and treatment for your pet.

Learn more

Common Questions

We offer insurance through a wide variety of carriers which means we can customize your options based on your specific needs. Whether it’s coverage for your home, or commercial insurance, we’ll help you get the best value for your money, while protecting the things you care about most.

Call us at (844) 498-6467 to talk to one of our insurance professionals who can help you gather the information you need to get insured.

Call us at (844) 498-6467 and our insurance professionals will be happy to help.

Your individual carrier may offer a website or mobile app to help you manage your insurance documents as well as your premium payments.